Why some knowledge can only survive the trip from one mind to another as a story
We all carry knowledge around — though the type, quality, and quantity of it varies wildly from person to person, and "knowledge" itself is surprisingly hard to pin down as a word. Still, every day we pick up new knowledge just by moving through the world. And we've built something remarkable on top of that: the ability to hand knowledge from one person to another, using nothing but language.
Take something as ordinary as a TV news reader. When they read out a bulletin, they're transferring knowledge to everyone watching. But news can be factually wrong, editors can carry bias, and sometimes what looks like news is really propaganda wearing a suit. So we take it with a pinch of salt — rightly.
Why scientific knowledge earns more trust
Scientific knowledge sits a rung above this in how much we trust it, and for good reason. It's a systematic process: collect information through observation and experiment, analyze it, and arrive at a conclusion. That conclusion then gets transferred to the scientific community through publication in journals.
Before publication, the work goes through peer review — other scientists checking it over. It isn't foolproof, but it's still the best filter we have. And the results speak for themselves: this method has given us cures for diseases, put humans on the moon, and turned phones into pocket computers.
A scientific paper follows a rigid format, and the language inside it is deliberately dry, colorless, precise — stripped of anything resembling emotion. That's not a flaw; it's a design choice. It leaves almost no room for the reader's imagination to wander in and distort the finding. A doctor won't prescribe a new medicine because of a newspaper column, a documentary, or a short film about it. He waits for the paper in a reputed journal. The same discipline holds across psychology, engineering, aviation, oceanography, mining — anywhere precision matters more than persuasion.
But precision has a ceiling
Here's the catch: this method of transferring knowledge has real limits.
Imagine a scientist goes to Mars and comes back. She wants to share the experience — so she sits down to write it up for a science journal. But this time she wants something more than an accurate record. She wants her readers to feel what she felt while she was up there.
Can a dry, colorless scientific format actually do that?
She may have lived through anxiety, fear, a rush of achievement, a sense of pure awe, an aching longing to be back on Earth with her child. In principle, all of that could be captured as data — specific EEG readings, shifting neurotransmitter levels, hormone fluctuations recorded in real time while she felt each thing. Say we had all of that logged and sitting in front of her as she writes.
Even so — pack every chart, table, and graph of that data into the paper, and it still won't let even an expert neuroscientist actually feel what she felt on Mars. To transmit that, you need an entirely different mode of communication: storytelling.
The knowledge that only survives as a story
Some kinds of knowledge can only travel this way. And I don't mean "moral of the story" knowledge — the tidy lesson at the end. Stories and myths shift our understanding in a way that's subtler and deeper than anything the actual sentences say on the surface. When someone tells a story well, they aren't just informing you — they're painting a picture directly onto your mind.
That's also why a good story resists being summarized. Try to compress one down and hand it to someone else, and the essence slips out through the gaps — the very thing that made it knowledge in the first place gets lost in the retelling. Poetry suffers from this even more than prose. Compress a poem into its "point," and you're left holding an empty shell.