I looked at Lewis. His eyes were bloodshot from lack of sleep. He was a brilliant young experimental physicist, while I was just an ordinary photon in his lab.
I was the study subject for his delayed choice quantum eraser experiments.
For the 16th time that night, he repeated the experiment. And I shot ahead and created the most beautiful interference pattern on the detector screen. He looked at the pattern on the detector and shook his head in frustration.
He couldn't figure out how I had precisely guessed that he would not be observing which path I took this time.
In the previous iteration of the experiment, he had decided to observe my which-way path, and that time I had given him a perfect non-interference pattern.
I was already losing interest in this game as Lewis tirelessly kept repeating the experiment on and on. I knew what was bothering him. No matter how he tweaked his experiment, it seemed that I precisely knew whether or not he would observe my travel path each and every time.
And most importantly, I knew it even before he made the conscious decision to observe or not observe my path. It didn't matter if he decided to do the observation remotely from his home computer or check results after the two-day weekend gap.
Lewis walked up to the desk and slumped into his chair. He reclined his back and closed his eyes. It was past midnight, and he was exhausted. I looked at him and felt a tinge of pity for him. Soon he was fast asleep.
I jumped off the detector screen and stood on the floor. There was silence in the lab except for some low-volume whirrs and beeps. Then I walked over to the big glass window overlooking the city and looked outside. The whole city in the night was breathtakingly beautiful, bathed in the lights illuminated by my brothers and sisters.
I walked over to Lewis, pulled a chair, and sat opposite him. I watched his innocent face for a few minutes and then decided to wake him up.
I shook his knees gently with my hands.
"Hey Lewis, wake up."
Lewis was in a deep sleep. But after some effort, Lewis slowly opened his eyes. He looked at me and didn't seem shocked at first as I had expected.
He slowly realized that he was in his lab in the middle of the night, and a stranger was sitting opposite him.
Lewis looked at his watch instinctively and then looked at me.
"Who are you? What are you doing here?"
I was not sure how to answer.
"What are you doing here in my lab?" Lewis started to get up as he searched me with his eyes.
"Lewis, I can explain, but I will need some time."
"How do you know my name?"
"I heard people calling you by this name. I have been living inside this lab for a few weeks now."
"I am going to call the security," Lewis said as he reached for the phone. Lewis was starting to panic.
"Wait… wait, I just wanted to discuss your experiments."
"Who are you?" Lewis asked again. There was impatience in his voice.
"My name is Photon."
"What kind of a name is that? Is this some kind of a prank?"
"It doesn't matter what my name is. What really matters is who I am."
"Ok man, now tell me who you are and what you're doing here in my lab." Lewis was fast losing his patience.
"Lewis, please sit down for a moment and let me show you something."
Lewis reluctantly sat down on the chair.
I waited for Lewis to settle down a bit.
"Now I will show you something and don't be shocked at what you are about to witness."
I got up and went to the whiteboard mounted on the wall. Then I turned around and faced Lewis and smiled.
My body transitioned slowly into a pleasant, transparent blue light. I then jumped into the whiteboard and became a blue display on it.
'I AM PHOTON,' was the display which Lewis could see now.
Then I flickered and danced on the whiteboard for a few moments.
Lewis was frozen in his chair, and his eyes seemed to pop out in disbelief.
Then I changed my display to:
'BE CALM. I WILL RETURN.'
I then transitioned back to the previous form and stood on the floor. I walked back and sat on the chair facing Lewis.
Then I poured a glass of water and handed it to him.
Lewis mechanically took the glass and sipped the water.
"Now, Lewis, listen to me carefully. I am here to help you understand the results of your experiment."
Lewis didn't speak.
"Ok, let us start with the most obvious question."
Lewis still remained silent.
"How do I know in advance whether or not you will ultimately decide to detect which path I took in the double-slit experiment?"
I waited for Lewis to say something.
"Yes, that is the puzzle," Lewis said, at last very slowly.
"There are many possible ways to answer this question, but do you have any thoughts of your own, Lewis?" I asked.
Lewis drank the water from the glass. He seemed more relaxed.
"I was really starting to wonder whether our understanding of time itself is wrong," he said.
"Like?"
"Whether the orderly sequence of events, from cause to effect is only an illusion."
"You mean retro-causality?" I asked.
"Something like that," Lewis replied.
"Well, that is one of the ways we could interpret it. But there can be alternate interpretations as well."
"I don't want any interpretations from you. Just tell me what the truth is," Lewis said.
I laughed and got up.
"Be patient, Lewis."
I walked up to the window and looked again at the beautiful city in the night.
Then I turned to Lewis and said:
"If all events in the universe are deterministic, we can explain the experimental results."
"You mean to say that all events are already pre-determined, which includes my decision to observe or not observe the photon path?"
"Yes. If that is the case, your brain's decision to make or not make a 'which-path' observation and the interference pattern on the detector are all part of one whole pre-determined connected system," I explained to him.
Lewis sat in silence, thinking about what I had just said.
Then he looked at me.
"But I have a doubt. Why is it that an opposite result is never observed?"
"You mean detecting the 'which-way' path the photon took, but still getting an interference pattern?"
"Yes. There would be no violation of any laws of physics, if such an observation were to take place."
"I don't know the answer," I said.
"How can you not know? You exist in that world and do these things," Lewis said with a tone of frustration.
I walked back and sat down in the chair opposite Lewis.
I was wondering whether to answer this question or leave it unanswered.
"You didn't answer." But Lewis persisted.
"Well, Lewis, the truth is that I don't know."
"How can you not know, I don't believe you."
I at last decided to take the conversation forward.
"We now come to more fundamental questions here Lewis," I said.
"Like what?"
"You have to understand that I don't exist independently of you."
"What do you mean? I can observe you with my experiments as can anyone else."
"That is true. But ironically, I come into existence only when you or someone observes me."
"You mean without someone to observe, you don't exist?"
"Yes. The observer and the observed cannot be separated."
"Do you mean to say that you are only a figment of my imagination?" Lewis asked.
"Not exactly correct. Your imagination itself is just another of your observations."
After a brief pause I continued:
"You are the 'observer'. And your thoughts, imaginations, dreams, and emotions are all 'the observed'."
Lewis looked like he was taken aback a bit. He looked away from me and stared blankly at the window. I could imagine that all the events of the night must have been too much for him.
Then he slowly reclined his back to the chair and closed his eyes. He seemed oblivious to my presence as I waited for him to open his eyes and speak to me. But I soon realized that he had fallen asleep. I didn't want to wake him up again.
I decided to go back to my world. I walked over to the detector screen and looked back at Lewis again. He would wake up in the morning and probably recall everything that happened as just a dream.
I jumped back into the detector and disappeared as a dying blue dot blip on the screen.